The Good, the Bad and the Ugly Forum < The Good, the Bad and the Ugly < Is this a crop too far?
. 1 . 2 .
Author Message
# Posted: 30 Oct 07 12:22
Reply 


any advise please
432372
432371
432129

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 12:37
Reply 


For my personal taste number 3 is the best crop. The panorama format enhances the composition of the bridges as a long structure and removes some distracting elements like the bushes in the foreground and the white cloud in the sky.

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 12:37
Reply 


I prefer the middle one: without the not-too-interesting foreground (with telephone lines), and keeping the sky.

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 14:23
Reply 


As ortho 158, I prefer the second one : we can see all the landscape, we can really get lost in the photo because we have space for it.
But I prefer the light on the bridge on the first one.
Cordialement

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 14:50
Reply 


For the same reasons than ortho158, I prefer the second one.

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 17:51
Reply 


And I agree with the others, the second one !!

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 19:09
Reply 


Definitively the second one...

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 19:24
Reply 


I agree with Pansa, number 3 is the most beautiful IMO.

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 21:14
Reply 


I'm for the second one.

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 22:23
Reply 


For me it's number two.

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 22:49
Reply 


For me also number two!

Greetings, Rikus

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 23:10
Reply 


bfurphy -

I agree with pansa : no. 3 gives me the full picture, with all distracting detail removed.

Regards

Geoff. ( Geoffrey McElwaine )

# Posted: 30 Oct 07 23:58
Reply 


I prefer number 2. The details like foreground and sky are not distracting. On the contrary, they give depth to your picture.

# Posted: 31 Oct 07 02:47
Reply 


I too prefer number 2. It gives a nicely balanced picture. The tilt disturbs me a bit though or is it the converging angles?

# Posted: 31 Oct 07 08:46
Reply 


for me it is number 2, I would have cropped a tiny bit more to loose the little green leaf in the middle, it is a wonderfull picture!

# Posted: 31 Oct 07 09:48
Reply 


Thank you everybody for all your comments I learn something different with each one and thank you bruha, I really must keep an eye on those horizons

Barbara

# Posted: 31 Oct 07 20:23
Reply 


The number 3 but with a little more sky.

# Posted: 1 Nov 07 00:17
Reply 


Number 3 for me !

# Posted: 1 Nov 07 00:18
Reply 


I think No 3 is the best one - the eye follows the bridge and beyond to the beautiful Isle of Skye.

# Posted: 2 Nov 07 07:06
Reply 


I would go for the middle one.

. 1 . 2 .
Your reply
Bold Style Italic Style Underlined Style URL Link    :) ;) :( :D ...  


You have to sign in to post messages
 
Most users ever online: 12 [24 Nov 08 22:25]  Guests - 1  Members - 11 Online now: Guests - 2  Members - 2
These forums are running on forum software miniBB™ © 2001-2008